Can a 2D person walking on a Möbius strip prove that it's on a Möbius strip?

2.2k Views Asked by At

Or other non-orientable surface, can a 2D walker on a non-orientable surface prove that the surface is non-orientable or does it always take an observer from a next dimension to prove that an entity of a lower dimension is non-orientable? So it always takes a next dimension to prove that an entity of the current dimension is non-orientable?

2

There are 2 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

If the person is in a Möbius strip, then it seems we are assuming he is $2$-dimensional. Suppose he has with him two identical circles split into sectors of $120^{\circ}$, and each sector is colored a different color. Notice being $2$-dimensional, he can rotate this circle but not reflect it, so the two circles are identical up to a rotation.

Now, let him leave one circle at a point, and wander around. If he ever returns to the point where he left the first circle, and he finds that the two circles cannot be rotated to match each other, then he knows he is living on a non-orientable manifold.

0
On

If he has a friend then they both can paint their right hands blue and left hands red. His friend stays where he is, he goes once around the strip, now his left hand and right hand are switched when he compares them to his friends hands.