Convexity and concavity in a textbook figure of the fundamental solution of the heat equation $u_t - u_{xx} = 0$

516 Views Asked by At

My textbook has this image of the fundamental solution of the heat equation $u_t - u_{xx} = 0$ for $0.25 \le t \le 10$:

enter image description here

It says that, when we deduce from the PDE that at locations where $u_{xx} < 0$ (so $u$ is convex in $x$) the solution decreases in time at fixed $x$ whereas, when $u_{xx} > 0$ (so $u$ is concave) the solution increases in time. The points of inflection, where $u_{xx}$ changes sign, separate regions where the solution is increasing in time from those where it is decreasing.

Convex vs. Concave:

enter image description here

Am I thinking about this incorrectly, or does this description not match the figure provided? For constant $x$ "beneath" the line (when $u$ is convex in $x$), we see that the solution decreases till about $t = 1$ and then actually increases. And, for constant $x$ "above" the line (when $u$ is concave in $x$), the solution actually decreases in time till about $t = 1$ and only then seems to increase.

Hmm, I'm not sure if I'm interpreting this incorrectly, or if this is an error by the author?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

8
On BEST ANSWER

The author has accidentally switched the words "concave" and "convex", but if you ignore those two words and read the maths(which is what I did originally), he is correct :) Its nothing more than combining the PDE $u_t = u_{xx}$ with the fact that $u_t < 0$ means $u$ is decreasing (and similarly for increasing.)

I remember which way round things are by remembering that $x^2$ is convex, and $(x^2)'' > 0$.

I've also attempted to recreate the graph. Note the contour lines, showing the decrease in height at $x=0$. enter image description here

Not quite the same, but hopefully this helps. From different angles- enter image description hereenter image description here

Edit - I just found out that Geogebra has an online 3D grapher. It even has a mode for the oldschool red-blue 3D glasses. I recreated the graph again here, and this time its interactive.