I have tried messing with different symmetries and permutations but I am definitely stuck. What is the catch? Do I need to consider shapes that are more than 2 dimensional? Do I need to consider interactions between multilpe objects?
How does one arrive at such group, and what does it represent?
Thank you very much.
You were already on the right track with permutations, but didn't try enough.
Take the symmetric group $S_3$ and let $a=(23)$, $b=(12)$ and $c=(123)$. Then $$ abc=(23)(12)(123)=(132)(123)=(1), $$ but $$ acb=(23)(123)(12)=(13)(12)=(123). $$ So $abc$ has order $1$, whereas $acb$ has order $3$.