Curious habit, will I be late for work in n-days ? [Probability]

64 Views Asked by At

Here is an interesting problem of probability :

Everyday, I can either go to work with a car or with the sub. If I take the car, I will be late half of the time, whereas with the metro, only a fourth (1/4 of the time). If today I'm late, tomorrow, I'll change my way of commuting. So if one day I'm late using the car, the next day I'll use the subway.

I start this habit tomorrow, and tomorrow I'll have a chance $p$ to use the car.

1. What is the probability that I'm using the car the n-th day ?

2. What is the probability that I'm late on the n-th day ?


Here comes my answer. Can you please tell me if there are any mistakes ?

I ve set the event $C_n$ as taking the car on n-th day, $S_n$ for the sub. $R$ is the event "being late". The event $R^c$ is the contrary, beeing on time.

$$ P(C_n) = P( S_{n-1} \cap R ) + P( C_{n-1} \cap R^c )$$ by hypothesis.

$$ \begin{split} P(C_n) = & P( S_{n-1} ) P ( R \vert S_{n-1} ) + P( C_{n-1} ) P ( R^c \vert C_{n-1} ) \\ =& \frac 1 4 ( 1 - P( C_{n-1} ) ) + \frac 1 2 P( C_{n-1} ) \\ =& \frac 1 4 ( P( C_{n-1} ) + 1 ) \end{split} $$ that because I can either take the car of the subway, so the two event $S_n, C_n$ are creating a partition for each day

(Can you maybe clarify this statement ? I don't know how to precisely justify this point ; This is for this equality : $1 - P( C_{n-1} ) = P( S_{n-1} ) $).

Getting to this point, we recognise an arithmetico / geometrico sequence.

I think that we get this general expression : $$ P(C_n) = (\frac 1 4)^n ( p- \frac 1 3 ) + \frac 1 3 $$

So this would be the answer to the first point, and for the second point, we simply have to use the formula of total probability :

$$ P( R) = P( S_{n} ) \frac 1 4 + P( C_{n} ) \frac 1 2 = \frac 1 4 ( 1 + P( C_n ))$$

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

Your argument is sound. The equality you are worried about is find because you have to take either the car or the subway, so both sides are the probability you take the car. I didn't check your solution to the recurrence, but it looks good. It should converge to $\frac 13$ and it does.