derangements basic practice question 2

580 Views Asked by At

This is not HW just a practice question from the text.

Q.. (NOTE: I find that both part a and b say the same thing but the answers are different) Ten women attend a business luncheon. Each women checks her coast and a attache case. Upon leaving, each women is given a coast and case at random.

a. In how many ways can the coats and cases be distributed so that no woman gets EITHER of her possessions.

ans.$(d_{10})^2$ Would like to know why is this squared

b In how many ways can they be distributed so that no woman gets back both of her possessions.

ans. $n! * S(m,n)$ where $m= 2, n=10$ this ends up being equal to $0$ as $m<n$ (where $S(m,n)$ is stirling number of the second kind)

why are these two questions different and why is part a $(d_{10})^2$

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

Let $\sigma$ be a permutation of the coats in which no one gets her coat back, and let $\tau$ be a permutation of the cases in which no one gets her case back. Then the ordered pair $(\sigma, \tau)$ is a way that no one gets her full possessions back.

There are $D_{10}$ choices for $\sigma$, and for each choice there are $D_{10}$ choices for $\tau$.

As to the second question, if everyone gets her coat back, and no one gets her case back, that would certainly not be part of the count for (a). But it would be part of the count for (b).