Find value of $\lambda$

105 Views Asked by At

$S$ is a circle having center at $(0, a)$ and radius $b\lt a$. A variable circle centred at $(\alpha, 0)$ and touching the circle $S$ meets $X$ axis at $ M$ and $N$. A point $P=(0,\pm \lambda\sqrt {a^2-b^2})$ on the $y$ axis such that angle $MNP$ is a constant for any choice of $\alpha$ then find $\lambda$.

My work: I wrote down the equation of circle $S$ and I have tried using the cosine rule in the two triangles having the same constant angle $MNP$. I also tried using basic algebra and the Stewart's theorem in some of the triangles I could do work in. But this was of no use. Moreover so many of variables are confusing me a lot. Any help is greatly appreciated.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

3
On BEST ANSWER

There is no $\lambda$ such that $\angle MNP$ stays constant when $\alpha$ varies, since $\tan(\angle MNP)$ is a ratio of two segments, one of which is constant $\lambda \sqrt{a^2-b^2}\,$, while the other one clearly varies with $\alpha$.

The more interesting question, however, is whether such a $\lambda$ exists so that $\color{red}{\angle MPN}$ stays constant.

Let $c$ be the radius of the second circle, then the tangency condition gives:

$$\alpha^2 + a^2=(b+c)^2 \quad \iff \quad c = \sqrt{\alpha^2+a^2}-b$$

It follows that $M,N = (\alpha \pm c, 0)=\left(\alpha+b \pm \sqrt{\alpha^2+a^2}, 0\right)\,$, then with $p=\lambda\sqrt{a^2-b^2}\,$:

$$\require{cancel} \begin{align} \tan(\angle MPN) &= \tan(\angle OPN - \angle OPM) = \frac{\tan(\angle OPN)-\tan(\angle OPM)}{1+\tan(\angle OPN)\tan(\angle OPM)} \\[5px] &= \frac{\dfrac{\cancel{\alpha}+c}{p}-\dfrac{\cancel{\alpha}-c}{p}}{1+ \dfrac{\alpha+c}{p} \cdot \dfrac{\alpha-c}{p}} = \frac{2pc}{p^2+\alpha^2-c^2} \\[5px] &= \frac{2\lambda\sqrt{a^2-b^2}(\sqrt{\alpha^2+a^2}-b)}{\lambda^2(a^2-b^2)+ \cancel{\alpha^2}-(\cancel{\alpha^2}+a^2)+2b\sqrt{\alpha^2+a^2}-b^2} \\[5px] &= \frac{2\lambda\sqrt{a^2-b^2}(\sqrt{\alpha^2+a^2}-b)}{(\lambda^2-1)a^2-(\lambda^2+1)b^2+2b\sqrt{\alpha^2+a^2}} \\[5px] &= \frac{2\lambda\sqrt{a^2-b^2}}{2b} \,\cdot\, \frac{\sqrt{\alpha^2+a^2}\color{blue}{- b}}{\sqrt{\alpha^2+a^2}\color{blue}{-\dfrac{(1-\lambda^2)a^2+(1+\lambda^2)b^2}{2b}}} \end{align} $$

The latter does in fact not depend on $\alpha$ iff the $\color{blue}{\style{font-family:inherit}{\text{blue}}}$ terms are equal $\iff \lambda=\pm1\,$.