Forex rate: Expected value paradox

213 Views Asked by At

Let us suppose at present

1 dollar = 1 euro

After 1 year

There is 50% chance that 1 dollar = .80 euro ...[1]

And there is 50 % chance that 1 dollar = 1.25 euro ...[2]

Therefore expected value of 1 dollar after 1 year = .5*.8+.5*1.25 = 1.025 euro ...[a]

But statement 1 and 2 can be written as

There is 50% chance that 1 euro = 1.25 dollar ...[3]

And there is 50 % chance that 1 euro = .8 dollar ...[4]

Therefore expected value of 1 euro after 1 year = .5*.8+.5*1.25 = 1.025 dollar ...[b]

But statement [a] and [b] cannot be both right.

What is wrong here?

I don't know if this fits here? But this riddle was posed in this stat lecture https://youtu.be/UZjlBQbV1KU?list=PL2SOU6wwxB0uwwH80KTQ6ht66KWxbzTIo