Given 4 spheres is there a unique point where the distance to their surfaces is minimal?

209 Views Asked by At

Problem Description:

The radii $r$ of 4 spheres are $r_1,r_2,r_3,r_4>0$ .

The center points of the spheres are not on a plane.

The spheres can overlap.

The distance to the surface of the sphere is positive in the case a sphere encloses the point. The cost-function is therefore always positive or 0 (in the case all spheres intersect at exactly one point).

Intuition:

There has to be a unique point where the sum of the distances from the point to the surfaces of the 4 spheres is minimal.

Q1: Is there a proof that a unique minimum exists?

Q2: Is the cost-function monotonically decreasing when approaching this point?

Edit:

  1. In the comments it has been concluded, that the function can not be smooth.
  2. In the comments it has been concluded, that in case of equal radii the point is the Fermats point.
1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

There has to be a unique point where the sum of the distances from the point to the surfaces of the 4 spheres is minimal.

I expect there is the following counterexample. Let the centers of the spheres are the vertices of a regular tetrahedron inscribed in the sphere of radius $1$ centered at the origin $O$ and each sphere has radius $3$. If the cost function has a unique minimum at a point $P$ then by the symmetry $P$ should be the origin. The value of the cost function at the origin is $8$. Pick any vertex $V$ of the tetrahedron. Let $Q$ be the intersection point of the ray from $O$ towards $V$ with the sphere of radius $3$ centered at $V$. Then the value of the cost function at $Q$ should be $3\left(\frac{\sqrt{46}}2-3\right)\approx 1.173$.

Here is the graph of a two-dimensional counterpart.

enter image description here