Has something like "Knuth's Up-Arrow Factorial Notation" ever been used? If so, what practical uses does it have?

392 Views Asked by At

I was studying Knuth's up-arrow notation and I was wondering if ever something like "Knuth's up-arrow factorial notation" has ever been used. Now I know this probably isn't a recognizable term, because I made it up. My question is basically asking if something like that(possibly with a different name) has ever been used to create enormous numbers. I'll explain how it works:

Knuth's up-arrow notation works like this:

You have ab which results to ab or a * a * a ..... * a where the amount of a's are equal to b.

For example: 4↑3 would be 43 or 4 * 4 * 4 or 64.

Using double arrows is where the numbers start getting big. a↑↑b is equal to aaa..a where the amount of a's is equal to b.

For example: 4↑↑3 would be equal to 444 or 4256. That's a big number!

Enough explaining that. What I like to call "Knuth's up-arrow factorial notation" is where we use arrow notation but b is changed to b factorial.

For example: You have a↑!b which results to ab! or a * a * a ..... * a where the amount of a's are equal to b!.

So, 4↑!3 would be 43! or 46 or 4096. Double arrows get even crazier. 4↑↑!3 would be equal to 444444 which is an enormous number! To simplify that without using scientific notation would be 4444294967296. Basically it's just like Knuth's up-arrow notation but with the b variable put to a factorial.

So what I'm asking is if something like that has ever been used before or if it's something that could be put to practical use.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

AFAIK, such "factorials" are not named, and as far as constructing large numbers go, they are quite small. It appears as though all you've done is

$$a\uparrow^k!b=a\uparrow^k(b!)$$

which is a seriously pointless thing. I doubt on an practical use, even for the sake of making large numbers, since

$$a\uparrow^{k+1}b\gg a\uparrow^k(b!)$$

That is, your factorials don't add anything onto the strength of Knuth's up-arrow notation.

And on top of that, what's the point of making a new notation when we can already write it easily?