How can my proof of the $\Delta L = \frac{d_1 d_2}{L} \sin\alpha \Delta\alpha$ triangle property be improved?

99 Views Asked by At

The Exercises for The Feynman Lectures on Physics (New Millenium Edition 2014) asks the reader to prove the following formula in exercise 2.4 (a) pg. 2-1: $$\Delta L = \frac{d_1 d_2}{L} \sin\alpha \Delta\alpha \quad(1)$$ where $d_1$ & $d_2$ correspond to the fixed lengths of a triangle, $\alpha$ is the angle between $d_1$ & $d_2$, and L is the length of the side opposite to $\alpha$ whose length varies by $\Delta L$ when $\alpha$ is varied by a small amount, $\Delta\alpha$.

I attempted to find a justification by applying the law of cosines & varying a starting angle, $\alpha_1$, by $\Delta \alpha$:

Let $\ L_1$ correspond to the length of L associated with angle $\alpha_1$ and $\ L_2$ correspond to the length of L associated with angle $\alpha_2$. Then $$ \ {L_2}^2 - {L_1}^2 = d_1^2 + d_2^2 -2d_1d_2\cos\alpha_2-(d_1^2 + d_2^2 -2d_1d_2\cos\alpha_1) \\ (L_2-L_1)(L_2+L_1) = -2d_1d_2\cos\alpha_2+2d_1d_2\cos\alpha_1 \\ L_2-L_1 = \frac{2 d_1 d_2}{L_2+L_1} (\cos\alpha_1-\cos\alpha_2) \quad (2). $$ Since $\Delta\alpha$ is small, $L_2 \approx L_1$ and thus $L_2+L_1=2L_1$, or simply $2L$. Also, $L_2-L_1$ in (2) can be rewritten as $\Delta L$ to give $$ \Delta L = \frac{d_1 d_2}{L} (\cos\alpha_1-\cos\alpha_2) \quad (3). $$ These are my questions: Can the difference of cosines in (3) be rewritten using identities and/or small angle approximations to match (1)? Is there an algebra error? Or a brand new approach is needed?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

We can use the following trigonometric identity of the sum of two angles. $$\cos\left(\alpha_2\right)=\cos\left(\alpha_1 + \Delta\alpha\right) = \cos\left(\alpha_1\right)\cos\left(\Delta\alpha\right)-\sin\left(\alpha_1\right)\sin\left(\Delta\alpha\right)$$

For $\Delta\alpha\rightarrow 0$, We know that $\space\cos\left(\Delta\alpha\right)\rightarrow 1\space$ and $\space\sin\left(\Delta\alpha\right)\rightarrow \Delta\alpha$.

Therefore, the above equation can be written as, $$\cos\left(\alpha_2\right)=cos\left(\alpha_1\right)-\sin\left(\alpha_1\right)\Delta\alpha.$$

Now, substitute this value of $\cos\left(\alpha_2\right)$ into your equation (3) to get,

$$\Delta L = \frac{d_1 d_2}{L} \Big(\cos\left(\alpha_1\right)-\cos\left(\alpha_2\right)\Big)=\frac{d_1 d_2}{L} \Big(\cos\alpha_1-cos\left(\alpha_1\right)+\sin\left(\alpha_1\right)\Delta\alpha\Big)$$ $$\qquad\quad\qquad=\frac{d_1 d_2}{L} \sin\left(\alpha_1\right)\Delta\alpha.$$