If a circle and parabola touch each other and also have common root then what's the relationship between their coefficient?

85 Views Asked by At

Actually this question is from physics (projectile motion) but i believe its related more to maths here equation of parabola $$y=ax-5x^2-5(ax)^2$$ And that of circle $$x^2+y^2=(a/5(1+a^2))^2$$ where $a=\tan \theta$ link to original question https://physics.stackexchange.com/q/562407 Now they touch each other also they share a common root now we have to find the values of a Now this seems nonsense but if we add slider on graph to a then they seem to meet the required condition at $theta$ approximately equal to $73^\circ$ also no boundattion for initial velocity so ignore the $40 \space m/s$ velocity in graph we can take it $1\ m/s$ also the graph image please note that a here in image is <span class=$\theta$" />

But how do we prove that when $\theta=(\approx)73^\circ$ the circle and parabola meet the required condition of touching each other and having a common root as shown in graph please help me

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On BEST ANSWER

Let $r = \dfrac{a}{5(a^2+1)}$ be the radius of the circle (the way you wrote it is a bit ambiguous, but this is what you need for the parabola and circle to intersect at $x=r, y=0$). The resultant of $x^2 + y^2 - r^2$ and $y - (a x - 5 (1+a^2) x^2)$ with respect to $y$ is $${\frac { \left( \left( 5\,{a}^{2}+5 \right) x-a \right) \left( \left( 125\,{a}^{6}+375\,{a}^{4}+375\,{a}^{2}+125 \right) {x} ^{3}+ \left( -25\,{a}^{5}-50\,{a}^{3}-25\,a \right) {x}^{2}+ \left( 5 \,{a}^{2}+5 \right) x+a \right) }{ 25 \left( {a}^{2}+1 \right) ^{2}}} $$ This must be $0$ where the two curves intersect. The first factor in the numerator is $0$ at $x = r$, so the other factor in the numerator gives the other intersection. Now for the curves to be tangent at that point, we want this to have discriminant $0$ with respect to $x$. That discriminant turns out to be $$ (62500 (a^4-11 a^2-1)) (a^2+1)^6$$ so the value of $a$ must be the (positive real) root of $a^4 - 11 a^2 - 1$, which is $$ \sqrt{(11 + 5 \sqrt{5})/2} \approx 3.330190676 $$ This is $\arctan(\theta)$ where $\theta \approx 1.279079822$ radians or $73.28587546$ degrees.