Joint probability illustration on venn diagram and on a table

219 Views Asked by At

I find venn diagram and table are conflicting in terms of illustrate joint probability (table for discrete case).

Let's say for the following example: enter image description here We know that the joint probability of X and Y is the area of intersection X and Y over the total area.

Now let's say the following table describes the joint probability of X and Y as well: enter image description here

They are apparently conflicting because in the venn diagram there will always be a value of X, if given, the probability of Y is 0, since there is always a portion of X does not overlap with Y.

Because of this I have problem of understanding concept such as P(A|E1)+P(A|E2)+...=1. It is used in the proof for the concept in this post:Proof that conditional probabilities sum up to one

Since joint probability is well-defined on a venn diagram it is supposed to make sense.