Probability of child1 given child2 =?

86 Views Asked by At
  • Let A, B and C be 3 random variables with binary outcomes $\{0,1\}$ defined by the probabilistic graph model below.
  • If B is observed as $(B=1)$ & A and C are not observed.
  • What is the probability that C = 1 given B = 1?
  • We have $P(B|A)$, $P(C|A)$ and $P(A)$

I am searching for the formula only.

enter image description here

2

There are 2 best solutions below

6
On

I assume the random variables are chosen uniformly? If that's the case:


"I am searching for the formula only."

Then i guess this is the formula you're after?:

∀ x∈U: P(x) = 1/|U|

the above formula(called the Uniform Distribution) Means that,

  • for all/every(∀) element x in(∈) Universe(U):
  • the Probability of x is 1 ÷ the size of U (denoted |U|)

A try at the answer itself: Correct me if I'm wrong: Isn't the probability that C = 1 given B=1, 1/3 or, 0,3?


Am I missing something?

6
On

Your notation seems to be conflicted about whether $A,B,C$ are binary random variables or events. I'm going to go with events because that makes writing things easier, but of course, these are equivalent.

Also, I am assuming $B$ and $C$ are conditionally independent given $A$, which you've implied but not actually said outright.

In that case, we can figure out $\Pr[A \cap B \cap C]$ as $\Pr[A] \cdot \Pr[B \mid A] \cdot \Pr[C \mid A]$. (Normally, this would have $\Pr[C \mid A \cap B]$, but we are assuming conditional independence here.) We can also figure out $\Pr[A^c \cap B \cap C]$ as $\Pr[A^c] \cdot \Pr[B \mid A^c] \cdot \Pr[C \mid A^c]$.

Finally, $\Pr[B \cap C] = \Pr[A \cap B \cap C] + \Pr[A^c \cap B \cap C]$, and $\Pr[C \mid B] = \frac{\Pr[B \cap C]}{\Pr[B]}$.