Probability patient has disease given positive test and a symptom

104 Views Asked by At

I am having trouble figuring out what 'Assuming that the accuracy of the test is not affected by the presence of symptom Y' means in the following problem in terms of the events: A - test is positive, B - patient has disease X, C - patient has symptom Y.

First part:

enter image description here

Second part:

enter image description here

EDIT: The exercise is from Victor Shoup's free book A Computational Introduction to Number Theory and Algebra, pages 216 (example 8.13) and 220 (exercise 8.10): https://shoup.net/ntb/

1

There are 1 best solutions below

5
On

It means that $\mathsf P(A\mid B,C)=\mathsf P(A\mid B)$ and $\mathsf P(A\mid\overline B,C)=\mathsf P(A\mid\overline B)$; that is, that you can keep using the four numbers for the accuracy of the test in the first part and only have to adapt the $1\%$ rate of incidence (since the incidence among people with symptom $Y$ is higher).

This means that $A$ is conditionally independent of $C$ given $B$ or $\overline B$; that is, while $\mathsf P(A\mid C)\gt\mathsf P(A)$ (a person with symptom $Y$ is more likely than average to test positive for the disease), so that $A$ and $C$ are not independent, they become independent when you condition on $B$ or on $\overline B$. That is, the test accuracy only depends on the presence of the disease; it depends on the presence of the symptom only in that this makes it more likely that the disease is present, but given whether the disease is present, the symptom has no influence of its own on the test results. For more on conditional independence, you may want to take a look at Could someone explain conditional independence?.