Probability Question: Minimum Possible Number of Marbles in a Bag

218 Views Asked by At

Here is the problem that I'm trying to solve:

Given a bag filled with red and white marbles, the probability of choosing a red and a white marble without replacement is 2/5. What is the minimum possible number of marbles in the bag?

I tried solving this problem with events probability, so I wrote the following equations:

Let R be the number of red marbles and W be the number of white marbles

We have (R/(R+W)) * (W/(R+W-1)) + (W/(R+W)) * (R/(R+W-1)) = 2/5, or

2 * ((RW)/((R+W) * (R+W-1))) = 2/5, so

(RW)/((R+W) * (R+W-1)) = 1/5.

From here, I did some lucky guessing and found that when R = 4 and W = 1, the equation holds, given me an answer of 5. However, I don't think that this was the intended solution, so can somebody please tell me of another solution that doesn't require guessing and checking?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

You can rewrite $$\frac{rw}{(r+w)(r+w-1)}=\frac15$$ as

$$5rw=(r+w)(r+w-1)\,;$$

if you let $n=r+w$, you can rewrite this as

$$5r(n-r)=n(n-1)\,.$$

Clearly $5$ must be a divisor of $n$ or $n-1$, so the smallest possible value of $n$ is $n=5$. Then $r(5-r)=4$, which can be solved by inspection or by solving the quadratic, which factors readily as $(r-4)(r-1)=0$.