Surface integral in divergence theorem when centre of sphere is not at origin

929 Views Asked by At

(I don't know why this question posted by me has been migrated here from physics stackexchange website; do I need to tell people in physics group that there exists "mathematical physics" tag in physics website? Do I need to tell people that electrodynamics which is nothing but vector field theory is physics stuff ? !!)

Consider spherical co-ordinate system. Let vector field be $ \vec V = k \vec r $.

$k$ is constant.

Consider a sphere of radius $R$.

I want to verify divergence theorem using this sphere and above mentioned vector field.

(a) When centre of sphere is at the origin of co-ordinate system, it is easy to verify divergence theorem.

$ \int_{vol} \vec \nabla.\vec V d \tau = \int_{surf} \vec V . \vec{da} $

We solve LHS, we get $ 4k \pi R^3$. We solve RHS, we get $ 4k \pi R^3$. And theorem is verified for this example of sphere.

(b) Now let us suppose centre of sphere is not at the origin (0,0,0); but at any but different location e.g. at $x=2R, y=2R, z=2R$. Evaluation of surface integral using spherical co-ordinates becomes hard in this case. Can anybody show how to evaluate this surface integral in spherical co-ordinate system?

By the way, I will be grateful if I get answers considering that I am a physicist and not mathematician!

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

This problem is equivalent to keeping the origin of coordinates fixed and instead integrate the flux of $\vec{V}'= k \vec{r} + \vec{b}$, with $\vec{b}$ a constant vector that takes care of the shift in position. The divergence of this vector is still $\nabla \cdot \vec{V}'= 3k \, .$ So we should find that $\int_{\mathcal{S}} \vec{b} \cdot \mathrm{d} a = 0$. This is simple to check: the flux of a uniform vector over a sphere vanishes.