Is a cone the only possible simple objects that can be created from a piece of circular thin plate with the greatest volume?

29 Views Asked by At

Given a piece of of circular plate with negligible thickness. We are allowed to cut the plate, use all or part of it and glue the edges to create a 3D object into which we can pour water (or any liquid).

Cutting the plate into infinitely many tiny pieces to create a bowl may be possible but it is not practical.

The solution that came into my mind is to create a cone by cutting the plate into two pieces of sectors. For a certain angle that can be found with differential calculus, one of the sectors produces a cone with the greatest volume.

Question

Is the cone the only possible solution with the greatest volume? How to prove this problem? I have no idea. Calculus of variation may help? But what function do I have to find to be maximized?

Edit

  • In the first step I have two cones. The smaller one can be merged as follows by creating a hole in the bigger one.

enter image description here

  • A piece of plate obtained by creating the hole above can also be used to create other cones.

  • Etc...