Oddly beautiful plot $x=\binom{x}{y}$

176 Views Asked by At

I recently stumbled across the plot, which is interesting both close up and further out!

$$x=\binom{x}{y}$$

It produces this contour plot (via Wolfram Alpha):

plot (x = (x choose y)), x from -5 to 5, y from -5 to 5

plot (x = (x choose y)), x from -5 to 5, y from -5 to 5 

plot (x = (x choose y)), x from -10 to 10, y from -10 to 10

plot (x = (x choose y)), x from -10 to 10, y from -10 to 10 

plot (x = (x choose y)), x from -1000 to 1000, y from -1000 to 1000

plot (x = (x choose y)), x from -1000 to 1000, y from -1000 to 1000

Does this plot have a name? Why does it look this way? As well, are there any other plots like this, with this type of interesting behavior?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

These plots are not quite correct. What's going on here is that ${x \choose y}$ is interpreted in terms of the Gamma function as $\frac{\Gamma(x+1)}{\Gamma(y+1) \Gamma(x-y+1)}$. I'll call this $c(x,y)$. However, $\Gamma$ has a singularity at nonpositive integers. The vertical lines at negative integer values of $x$ are due to those singularities. If $y$ is not an integer, $c(x,y) \to +\infty$ as $x$ approaches a negative integer value from one side and $+\infty$ as it approaches from the other side. The plotting software interprets that as a point on the curve.

Here's a somewhat more accurate plot produced by Maple. The green lines correspond to the singularities at negative integer values of $x$.

enter image description here